SmartPhoneToday

Home | News | Reviews | Features | FREE Downloads | Forums | Compare PDA Prices | Compare SmartPhone Prices


  BlackBerryToday > Features > The iPhone Has A Lot, But Not It All

The iPhone Has A Lot, But Not It All

By James Alan Miller
June 28, 2007

Click to View
The Apple brand, history and reputation for creating products people must have helped to set in motion the all-consuming buzz that put the iPhone in a different category from other smartphones that offer as much, if not more, in the way of features. As a result, Apple's is poised to successfully step into a far more competitive market with the iPhone than it did with the iPod six years ago. And, like with the iPod, the new phone/iPod/Internet device combo, for better or worse, is being treated as the second coming.

It's almost as if there aren't already products on the market that can make phone calls, play music and video, access the Internet for e-mail and the Web, taking pictures, etc. I'm not saying any of these smartphones are perfect, be they built on the Palm OS, Windows Mobile, Symbian or some flavor of Linux, but you wouldn't think they exist from the attention and coverage the iPhone is receiving.

Sure, there is much that Apple has done right to warrant this attention, not the least of which was allowing demand to build up for years before Steve Jobs stepped out on stage at MacWorld in January to introduce the iPhone for the first time.

Unless you've been living under rock for the last six months, you're likely aware of much of what the iPhone can do. And, from early reviews, it seems Apple has gotten much of that right; particularly with what is said to be a fantastic display and compelling and intuitive user interface. (The fact that they've implemented cover flow technology into the iPhone is enough to make it a compelling iPod alternative in my book.)

However, there are some features available in many of today's smartphones (and even some cell phones) that the iPhone does not have. While many of these may be able to be added or improved upon with software updates later, others clearly cannot until future generations of the iPhone.

Below is a list of missing features:

  • no MMS support to send pictures or video with text messages

  • no instant messaging client

  • no over the air (OTA) support for music downloads from iTunes (over AT&T's EDGE network or even Wi-Fi)

  • no wireless syncing over Wi-Fi or Bluetooth - can only sync through a cable connection to a PC or Mac

  • battery not removable - should the battery poop out, you'll have to go to Apple, as with the iPod, to replace it. Also, many folks like to carry around a spare battery, which you cannot do if the battery can't be removed.

  • 2 megapixel camera can't take video.

  • no flash

  • no hard keyboard

  • no Bluetooth Dial Up Networking - you can't use the iPhone as a modem for a laptop to access the Internet or enterprise

  • can't make ringtones out of audio files, even those from iTunes

  • No ability to cut, copy or paste!

  • no java or Flash support - the iPhone can play YouTube videos through a bundled applet, however.

  • no voice recognition or voice dialing

  • no support for Bluetooth wireless stereo headsets (A2DP)

  • no 3G - AT&T has the fastest data network (UTMS/HSPDA) among GSM carriers in U.S., and yet Apple chose to limit the iPhone to 2.5G EDGE technology, which is far far slower; painfully slow, as some reviewers have pointed out. The stated reason: EDGE is far more widely available than 3G. That's true. But in areas where 3G isn't available you automatically drop down to EDGE with other smartphones, so why not include 3G in the first place. Heck, it's been said the Safari browser in the iPhone is one of the best mobile browsers ever. Why not give it the juice to do its thing right when a Wi-Fi hotspot isn't around?

  • no GPS - Google Maps is nice, but combining it with a technology that could tell where you are would be even nicer.

  • no expandable storage - 4GB and 8GB seems like a lot of storage, and for most folks it is probably more than enough, but having an expansion slot would have given the iPhone unlimited expandability. It also would have been another convenient method for transferring and sharing files and documents.

  • a lack of SIM portability - while it is often the case that a cell phone or smartphone is locked by a carrier so it can't be used on another operator's network, it appears the iPhone may only work with the SIM it came with. You may not even be able to remove the SIM at all. That means AT&T customers who buy the iPhone may be locked to the iPhone. So, for example, I may not be able to pop the SIM I have in my Treo back and forth between that device and the iPhone.

  • it is said you can't use the touch screen and soft keyboard (the only means of entering data into the iPhone) with gloves on, as it looks like it requires skin contact. If true, you may quickly miss having several buttons, a hard keypad or keyboard, and stylus input on a cold day.

    Of course, none of the above matters to those who've already made up their mind to buy an iPhone. The iPhone's interface, display and, let's not forget, style is more than enough for many consumers who aren't used to having the features it does offer in a single device.

    After all, it's not those familiar with today's smartphones that Apple is targeting with the iPhone. We're the ones who are the most skeptical, after all. It's mostly folks who are, thanks to the Apple brand, hype and genuine interest, coming to a device like this for the first time that are making the difference with the iPhone.

    In the end, that can only be good for the smartphone market as a whole.



  • Related Links:

  • iPhone: From an IT Manager's Perspective
  • iPhone Hysteria
  • iPhone, Foleo - Canvases for 3rd Party Development?
  • What to Make of Recent iPhone Buzz
  • The iPhone Effect

     
     Printable Version
     Email this Story to a Friend  Add Your Opinion



    User Opinions:

    Total: 3 Opinions  -   Displaying: 3 of 3  Read More...


    iphone or 8925
    Is there soon to be an 8925 to take the place of the att 8525 ? I have a cingular 8125. I like the looks and feel of the iphone. However rumor has it , the 8925 might be one to look for. I have had my 8125 to lock up on me when I was in europe. I los...more

    Submitted by: Woody



    I almost was a victim
    I must say that when you see this fine specimen of a phone you wonder if you should have it or not. After reading this and realizing all the freedoms in a sense that I would be losing like external keyboard, expandable memory, being able to switch fr...more

    Submitted by: Merli Desrosier



    Interface
    "It is refreshing to see Apple break the mold of the cell phone as we've known it, opening windows for more market-defying, style-defining phones that draw attention to the full potential of a mobile device. Yet, to truly experience the content, ent...more

    Submitted by: Nuance



     Add Your Opinion  See All 3 Opinions >>



  • PDA/Smartphone Newsletters
    text html text html
    X WindowsMobileToday X PDAStreet
    X Palm Boulevard X SmartPhoneToday
    X BlackBerryToday X Pocket PC Wire
    X iPhoneGuide      

    Other Personal Technology Newsletters
    X Sharky Extreme X WiFi Planet


    internet.comearthweb.comDevx.commediabistro.comGraphics.com

    Search:

    Jupitermedia Corporation has two divisions: Jupiterimages and JupiterOnlineMedia

    Jupitermedia Corporate Info

    Legal Notices, Licensing, Reprints, Permissions, Privacy Policy.
    Advertise | Newsletters | Tech Jobs | Shopping | E-mail Offers

    Whitepapers and eBooks

    Symantec Whitepaper: Converging System and Data Protection for Complete Disaster Recovery
    Intel Whitepaper: Comparing Two- and Four-Socket Platforms for Server Virtualization
    IBM Solutions Brief: Go Green With IBM System xTM And Intel
    HP eBook: Simplifying SQL Server Management
    IBM Contest: Are You the Next Superstar? Join the "Search for the XML Superstar" Contest to Find Out
    Microsoft PDF: Top 10 Reasons to Move to Server Virtualization with Hyper-V
    Microsoft PDF: Six Reasons Why Microsoft's Hyper-V Will Overtake Vmware
    Microsoft Step-by-Step Guide: Hyper-V and Failover Clustering
    Intel PDF: Quad-Core Impacts More Than the Data Center
    Intel PDF: Virtualization Delivers Data Center Efficiency
    Go Parallel Article: PDC 2008 in Review
    Microsoft PDF: Top 11 Reasons to Upgrade to Windows Server 2008
    Avaya Article: Communication-Enabled Mashups: Empowering Both Business Owners and IT
    Intel Whitepaper: Building a Real-World Model to Assess Virtualization Platforms
      PDF: Intel Centrino Duo Processor Technology with Intel Core2 Duo Processor
    Microsoft Article: Build and Run Virtual Machines with Hyper-V Server 2008
    Go Parallel Article: Q&A with a TBB Junkie
    IBM Whitepaper: Innovative Collaboration to Advance Your Business
    Internet.com eBook: Real Life Rails
    IBM eBook: The Pros and Cons of Outsourcing
    Internet.com eBook: Best Practices for Developing a Web Site
    IBM CXO Whitepaper: The 2008 Global CEO Study "The Enterprise of the Future"
    Avaya Article: Call Control XML in Action - A CCXML Auto Attendant
    IBM CXO Whitepaper: Unlocking the DNA of the Adaptable Workforce--The Global Human Capital Study 2008
    Adobe Acrobat Connect Pro: Web Conferencing and eLearning Whitepapers
    Symantec Whitepaper: Comprehensive Backup and Recovery of VMware Virtual Infrastructure
    MORE WHITEPAPERS, EBOOKS, AND ARTICLES